RChavez
Registered: December 2011 City/Town/Province: El Paso Posts: 1
View this Member's Photo Gallery
|
Title: The Protection Furnished by Calcium Oxalate Against Acid Rain
Dedication: I want to acknowledge the following people who helped me with materials, critical suggestions, transportation, funding, and moral support. Sara and Ramon Chavez; Mrs. Sarah Welsh ;Ms. Cerverra, Mrs. Laura Vela, Mr. Ken Porter, Mr. Ruben Amador, Ms. Jessica White, and especially my sister who was sent to the E.R. because of my project.
Background Research: <Sulfuric Acid and Acidic Rain-
Sulfuric acid (H2SO4) is produced naturally in small quantities from the decay of organisms, but is almost entirely yielded by human activity. Sulfur dioxide is an intermediate in the production of sulfuric acid, being converted to sulfur trioxide, and then to oleum, which is converted into sulfuric acid. About 75% of acid rain is composed of sulfuric acid (Casiday, 1998). The combustion of sulfur-containing fossil fuels in power plants is the greatest cause of sulfuric acid and accounts for approximately 80% of the total atmospheric sulfur dioxide (SO2) (Casiday, 1998). This same sulfur dioxide reacts with water to form sulfuric acid. Sulfuric acid is a powerful acid that easily drops the pH of rainwater to extremely harmful levels.>
<Nitric Acid and Acidic Rain-
Nitric oxide (NO) is also a significant factor in the acidity of rainwater. NO is produced during lightning storms when nitrogen and oxygen react (Casiday, 1998). In its gaseous state nitric oxide is oxidized to create nitrogen dioxide (NO2) which reacts with water to create nitric acid (HNO3). Nitric acid is produced naturally in small amounts, but is mainly composed by high-temperature combustion, such as that found in car engines and power plants (Casiday, 1998). Nitric acid reacts violently with many organic materials and the reactions may be explosive. This acid greatly contributes to the harmful effects of acid rain on structures and wildlife.>
<Carbon Dioxide and the Natural Acidity of Rainwater
Carbon dioxide (CO2) contributes most to the natural acidity of rainwater. When carbon dioxide reacts with water, carbonic acid is formed. This carbonic acid has the ability to lower the pH of a solution, thus classifying this molecule as an acid. A large increase in the concentration of NO and SO2 significantly affects the pH of rainwater, even though both gases are present at a much lower concentration than CO2 (Casiday, 1998).>
<Calcite and Acid Rain
It is well established that either wet or dry deposition of sulfur dioxide significantly increases the rate of corrosion on limestone, sandstone, and marble. When sulfuric and nitric acids in polluted air react with the calcite in marble and limestone, the calcite dissolves (Watson, 1997). This is because calcite is soluble in water and, as a result, the limestone dissolves and crumbles. The exposed areas of buildings and statues usually begin to acquire roughened surfaces, removal of material, and loss of carved details when even a slight amount of acid rain comes into contact. Stone surface material may be lost all over or only in spots that are more reactive.>
<Vinegar as an Acid Rain Substitute
Acid rain is not vinegar, but vinegar is an acid, and can be used to create a solution that is similar to acid rain. In this experiment, vinegar will be used to imitate the harmful effects that acid rain has on a marble or limestone structure. The pH measurement system is determined by the neutral rating of 7, in which lower values are more acidic, and higher values contain more alkaline. Typical rainwater has a pH rating of 5.6 (Lansky 2004). Rainwater that is considered acidic has a pH rating of anything less than 5.6 (Lansky 2004). The pH of vinegar is 3.0, and, therefore, needs to be diluted with water. To create an imitation acid rain with a pH of 4.0, the following equation can be used;
20 ml (4 tsp) of vinegar + 2 liters (2 qt) of water = imitation acid rain with a pH of 4.>
Purpose: In today’s world, pollution and other filth seems to contaminate every bit of the air around us. Besides having disastrous effects on plant and animal life, acidic rain, which is caused by this pollution, can also have destructive effects on our buildings and homes made from limestone and marble. This experiment is aimed at discovering a new and more effective chemical that will protect against the harmful consequences of acid rain. As you read this paper, acidic rain around the world is destroying the structures that truly help identify our generation and the generations before us. It is our duty to stop this harmful process before it is too late.
Materials Used: 3 pieces of marble tile, each weighing 100 grams
1 bottle of oxalic acid
1 bottle of commercial marble sealant
3 beakers
1200 milliliters of vinegar
1 measuring cylinder
1 piece of cloth
1 sheet of sandpaper
1 weighing scale
Procedures Taken:
-Clean all 3 marble tiles.
-Using the digital weighing scale, ensure that they weigh exactly 100g each.
-If a tile weighs more than 100g, reduce its weight by sanding it down with the sandpaper.
-Record the starting weight of the marble tiles in a table.
-Place the first tile in a beaker labeled “No protection.�
-Polish the second tile with the commercial marble sealant according to the instructions on the packaging, and place it in a beaker labeled “Sealant.�
-Coat the third tile with oxalic acid, and place it in a beaker labeled “Calcium oxalate.�
Measure 1200ml of vinegar with the measuring cylinder and pour 400ml into each of the 3 beakers.
-To dilute the vinegar to better match the actual pH of acid rain, use the following equation, 20 ml (4 tsp) of vinegar + 2 liters (2 qt) of water = imitation acid rain with a pH of 4.
The vinegar solution will be used to simulate acid rain.
-At the end of the day, remove and wipe the tiles down lightly, and record their weights in the table, under “Day 1.�
-Repeat step 11 every day for the next 4 days, recording the new weights of the tiles in the table.
Data:
- According to the results, the marble without coating dissolved the quickest with a starting weight of 100 grams, a first day weight of 77 grams, a second day weight of 55 grams, a third day weight of 40 grams, a fourth day weight of 29 grams, and an ending weight of 17 grams.
-According to the results, the marble coated with marble sealant dissolved second quickest with a starting weight of 100 grams, a day 1 weight of 95 grams, a day 2 weight of 92 grams, a day 3 weight of 88 grams, a day 4 weight of 77 grams, and an ending weight of 71 grams.
-According to the results, the marble coated with oxalic acid dissolved the slowest with a starting weight of 100 grams, a day 1 weight of 99 grams, a day 2 weight of 96 grams, a day 3 weight of 91 grams, a day 4 weight of 84 grams, and an ending weight of 80 grams.
Analysis and Conclusion:
During the course of the experiment, the marble coated with the calcium oxalate dissolved least in the vinegar solution with an ending weight of 80 g. Secondly, the marble coated with the commercial sealant dissolved with an ending weight of 71 g. The marble without coating dissolved the quickest with an ending weight of 17 g. Therefore, oxalic acid coated on marble to create calcium oxalate serves as better protection against acid rain than marble coated with commercial marble sealant or without coating.
Although the commercial sealant does provide superior protection against other elements such as less acidic rainfall and hail, it does not provide the best protection against acidic rain. According to the results of my experimentation, when oxalic acid is applied fully on marble, the results of acid rain are much less devastating than other forms of sealant.
Society can greatly benefit from the findings of my experiment by becoming more aware of the dangers of pollution and how it can affect everything from plant and animal wildlife to the very structures that we reside in. Furthermore, the startling results of my experiment can also help to promote regular building maintenance.
Chances are that acidic rain is currently corroding the buildings in our neighborhoods, and, therefore, increases the likelihood that we can all be in extremely great danger from the risk of a building collapse. If architects and city inspectors continue to advocate regular building maintenance and preservation, we can prevent the possibility of this happening.
This experiment can be easily altered to produce slightly different results and provide different information to the engineers that strive to design buildings that will last for a lifetime. To broaden the range of buildings that are being harmed by acid rain, the experiment can be repeated by using limestone or wood instead of marble. Furthermore, instead of using oxalic acid, this experiment can test which brand of commercial marble sealant provides the best protection against acid rain. Scientists can use the results of my experiment and design a new and more effective sealant that contains calcium oxalate to better protect our precious buildings against the devastating repercussions of acid rain.
The Apprentice Ecologist Project has helped me to gather insight into the detrimental backlashes that human activity has caused to nature and our fragile environment. The results of this experiment opened my eyes and made me realize that more needs to be done to protect flora and fauna. In the future, I will work to further safeguard our precious environment by educating others of the results of my project and what they possibly mean to the world around us.
Bibliography:
Casiday, R., & Frey, R. (1998). Acid Rain Inorganic Reactions Experiment. Thesis, Washington University, St. Louis. Retrieved December 23, 2010
Hasan, H. (2007). Helium (First ed. ). New York City: The Rosen Publishing Group, Inc.
Khan, S. (2000). Calcium Oxalate in Systems. Boca Ration, FL: CRC Press, Inc.
Park, C. (1987). Acid rain: rhetoric and reality (Illustrated, reprint ed. ). Methuen.
Simon, C. A. (2007). Alternative Energy: Political, Economic, and Social Feasibility. Lan ham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.
Vezirolu, N. (2007). Alternative energy sources: an international compendium. Miami: Hemisphere Publishing Corporation.
|